Re: Re: 100 Greatest Games of All Time!
 

I know... I said LttP was beat out BY those two games... I think LttP is the best Zelda game ever overall...

'Course that's just my opinion, and as Crono_link said in his last post, the list was made based on review scores...

Re: Re: Re: 100 Greatest Games of All Time!
 

*shakes head*
that list wasnt even worth reading
when will the world learn that reviews mean nothing its how the game is played by people who dont get payed to play the game that counts damn them *shakes fist harder then deathshand then passes out from shaking fist*

The score is an average of many review scores. So it's not just one person's opinions. It takes many people's opinions and compiles them to get a final score.

The problem is hype.

It's silly that they have the same games on there... Like they have A link to the Past for game boy advance, then A link to the past for SNES...Even though that should be in the top 5, but that's just me.

4. Madden NFL 2004 -Playstation 2


Thats disgusting.

This is the worst list I have ever seen, and its also a horrible way to make a list, if they had compared the games or put them into separate lists by genre at least we would'nt get Madden NFL 2004 being the fourth best game of all time, this list makes me sick.

Edit: where's the Super Mario RPG? that should have easily made the list.

But Madden NFL 2004 is such a great game.

Sorry you guys don't like sports games.
But it is the best sports game ever made. Doesn't a great sports game deserve a high score?

Its not that I don't like sports games I just think that Madden NFL 2004 is'nt the fourth best game of all time, and that list has one horrible flaw: that it only takes reviews so, any hyped up game despite how good it is could get a few really good reviews by fans and then make it to the top of the list where it doesnt belong. Also sleeper hits that are great but not well known(like the Suikoden series) don't make it on the list at all.