Knockin' on Heaven's Door: Which is superior?
 

Contender One - Bob Dylan:



Contender Two - Guns n' Roses:



Contender Three - Avril Lavigne:

Re: Knockin' on Heaven's Door: Which is superior?
 

I've always liked Avril's music so I vote her.

Re: Knockin' on Heaven's Door: Which is superior?
 

Bond, you already failed for not including Clapton's version. I can't vote until he is given credit.

Re: Knockin' on Heaven's Door: Which is superior?
 

Haha, Clapton's version is actually my favorite, especially considering the circumstances around which he sang the song... but I wanted to mix it up a little bit.

Re: Knockin' on Heaven's Door: Which is superior?
 

Okay, good answer. By the way, I have more respect for you now.

It's hard for me to choose between Dylan and Guns n' Roses, but I gotta go with the originator.

Re: Knockin' on Heaven's Door: Which is superior?
 

..I can't pick any of them. And not because I like them all.

I'll tell you what I won't pick though. GNR's. KNOWCK KNOWCK KNOWCKIN ON HEAVEN'S DOWAHOURRRRRRRRRRRRRR HEEEYYY HEEEEEEEEEEYY HYEEEEEEEEEEEY HEY HEY.

Re: Knockin' on Heaven's Door: Which is superior?
 

Agreed. I remember hearing this on the radio at 2 AM once and thinking that it must be one of the most absurd vocal takes ever put to tape. I mean, seriously? I couldn't stop laughing thinking of the song without the music and just hearing Axl belt it out. It's ridiculous.

Re: Knockin' on Heaven's Door: Which is superior?
 

Dylan.

Re: Knockin' on Heaven's Door: Which is superior?
 

Didnt even have to listen to them


Robert Zimmerman

Re: Knockin' on Heaven's Door: Which is superior?
 

I've always been a fan of Dylan's version.

Re: Knockin' on Heaven's Door: Which is superior?
 

Bobert.

Re: Knockin' on Heaven's Door: Which is superior?
 

Gonna go with the one I grew up on... and hope its right.

Reggae version.
Which believe was sung by Marley.

Re: Knockin' on Heaven's Door: Which is superior?
 

Yup, twas Bob Marley.

Parents played both Bobs growing up. Not sure which I prefer. Think Marley.

Re: Knockin' on Heaven's Door: Which is superior?
 

Yes?

Re: Knockin' on Heaven's Door: Which is superior?
 

I probably gravitate towards the Guns N Roses version....it's the one I hear the most. But I also like the rawness of Dylan's original.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Knockin...eaven%27s_Door

It's been covered by A LOT of artists. It's an okay song, maybe I would like it more if it wasn't played so much? It's certainly not a good representation of Dylan's long and amazing career. :p So, on that note, it is one of Guns N Roses better songs, which says a lot about how much they suck. So yeah, I think I prefer the Axl Rose version.

Re: Knockin' on Heaven's Door: Which is superior?
 

I really do not like Dylan or Avril. Guns 'N Roses for me.

Re: Knockin' on Heaven's Door: Which is superior?
 

The fact that Dylan is beating GNR in this poll is disgusting. You folks have no taste!

Re: Knockin' on Heaven's Door: Which is superior?
 

in retrospect I wonder who is more tasteless, Avril or Guns N Roses.

Re: Knockin' on Heaven's Door: Which is superior?
 

Joke post?

Re: Knockin' on Heaven's Door: Which is superior?
 

Joke character? No, we all know that GNR wins at Knockin' on Heavens door. Just because it's your precious Bob Dylan doesn't mean that he's the best at everything.

Re: Knockin' on Heaven's Door: Which is superior?
 

GNR wins at being so ridiculous it's good, but that doesn't make it better than the original.

He's not "my precious". If I had the choice, I would've taken Clapton's version. I'd take Clapton over Dylan any day.

Re: Knockin' on Heaven's Door: Which is superior?
 

Ick. No GNR, for the reason Dyne put. For me the GNR version is very obnoxious.

Dylan by default.