Hm.... well, sport games can be very fun, but I don't consider them super games.
Perhaps that's biased, but I just need a story, adventure and emotions in a game.
Sure, we had a lot of fun with Super Smash Bros, but I don't think it's better than let's say Eternal Darkness. Even though I've played SSB A LOT MORE.
Damn it, the guy in the bar is the most cowardly?
And you need the colour pictobox for the moon??
I beated it yesterday night, the endig didn't make up for the rest of the game. Crappy story. Even though it was hard enough.