View Single Post

Re: Harry Potter: Goblet of Fire
Old 11-20-2005, 10:13 PM   #16
MuGen
Fuuton Rasenshuriken
 
MuGen's Avatar
 
MuGen is offline
Location: Cali
Now Playing: Enchanted Arms PS3
Posts: 2,483
Default Re: Harry Potter: Goblet of Fire

I really don't know where you get weak acting.

Quote:
Too many really awkward moments with poor acting and wooden dialogue, and many scenes that tried hard to be dramatic without actually having substance.
I'm trying to understand what you mean by 'dramatc without actually having substance.'

The only scene I could think of that would bring up that question is

********SPOILER****************










is when Hermione is at the dance, and cries when Ron gives her the cold shoulder.

Far be it for me to understand that she is a 15 year old girl who was just told that her date is just using her and doesn't really like her by a jealous friend.

Dramatic yes, not enough substance? Maybe not for you but for a 15 year old girl, that can have as much substance as a full cup of milk.














*****************************************************



As an individual I thought the acting was good. Not the best, but good.
But I have to agree w/ Dyne. If you think this movie had poor dialogue and awkward moments, it's only because you imagined them being portrayed differently from the book, and the dialogue didn't follow the book to the tee.

This is the kind of critique movies from Comics get, and movies from games get....

The more I take the time to understand the more I come to the conclusion that people are more likely to compare the movie to the book rather then critique the movie as a movie.
__________________

Last edited by Sony : 11-20-2005 at 10:19 PM.
  Reply With Quote