For the record, if millions of people love a game, and you happen to be a member of a small minority that hate it, that does not mean the game sucks.
It means its a great game you don't like. And there is nothing wrong with that.
My issues with the list:
1) Anything Metroid Prime does not belong in the top 50.
2) I'm suprise neither Super Mario Ball Scrarching (import) and Legend of Zelda: Because It Makes Money didn't make the list. A little overkill.
3) Regardless of you feelings on Halo, it belongs in the top ten just because of its influence on the industry. It is the Super Mario Bros of the modern gaming era.
4) River Raid and Nintendo Ice Hockey belong in the top 20 just because I said so.
Overall, not that bad of a list. Just too heavy on Mario, Zelda and old role playing games. Strategy should have had a better representation as well, I think.