[Yoda9864]

A 10 for me is a game that keeps me coming back multiple times to play it again and again. It doesn't have to be perfect, technically speaking, but it has to have very solid gameplay mechanics.

What games are 10s for me? Easy.

Chrono Trigger. Ocarina of Time. Oblivion.

Three games that I have come back to over and over again. I have beaten each of these games at least 3 times. Even if I'm fighting the same people and doing the same things, the games are so fun and I have felt the need to play them again, and again...and again. One big thing is that they are complex, yet simple to play.

I do have a couple games that come close to 10s and I feel bad for not giving them 10s because I've played them so much: Half Life 2, RollerCoaster Tycoon 2, Super Metroid.