A game that is *fun*
In order from highest to lowest priority:-
1. Innovation/Gameplay > something fresh and unique in its own right that sets it apart from the rest. Tight controls, variety in gameplay, pure fun, unexpectable moments from the game!
2. Music > Immersive music that I reminisce to , and music that makes me want to download the songs and listen to them on the attrac3+ player
3. Visuals > As glitch free as possible, colourful, sharp, nice on the eye
4. Online/Multiplayer > Some options for onilne would be nice, downloadable content.
5. Story > A story that's easy to follow, not full of many unecessary twists, just smooth flowing and real to that specific genre of gaming
That'll do it me thinks.
PS Kudos to Dyne for bringing this up
