[Angrist]

Although I've come to appreciate The Wind Waker after a few years, I like TP so much better. The realistic graphics made the world more capturing for me, even though the cartoon style of TWW got pretty nice after a while.

TWW just had so many annoyances:
Bad puzzles
Not enough dungeons
Slow travel
Boring items (who ever came up with that slow graple hook animation?? Why does the sail always stay a usable item instead of a standard feature of your boat??) (although the Deku Leaf and Pictobox are items I'd love to see again)
Bad gameplay choices, like when you fall down and have to walk all the way up again.

The story of Twilight Princess really moved me. At 3/4 it sududenly got boring... no more story elements between the last few dungeons.

If we're comparing steps forward in the genre, I guess TWW would win. TP didn't add that much, it was more of a perfection of past ideas.