Ok, everyone rush and say their preconceived opinion about the matter! Don't bother reading the article, just post!
And.... I don't have time atm to go through the article on a point by point basis. Anyone else up for it?
My personal preconceived opinion is that I agree, I much prefer Wii FPS games to Dual-Analog. I can't stand dual-analog shooters. Third-person shooters are ok, but I think that's because they tend not to focus entirely on shooting. I think I would have skipped Uncharted 1&2 if it was first-person, or if everything else about the game besides shooting wasn't as good as they were.