I read half of the article and I don't really agree with it so far.
I agree with his conclusion, but not with his reasoning. For me FP Wii games are fun and immersing, but I especially like how easy it is to look/move around. Playing MP3 feels so good, probably even better than on PC.
I could do without all the movement-based actions. Opening a door with a motion? That often takes too long. And when the motion control is imperfect, it only distracts me.
I'd really like to see how the next gen will combine HD with motion control.
