So evidently this game is pretty good. Currently has a 95% on metacritic,
http://www.metacritic.com/game/pc/bioshock-infinite, and has its fair share of perfect review scores.
Here's Adam Sessler's review:
I actually never played the first one...I know, probably missed one of the greatest games of this generate, but it also had a lot of "jump scares" in it, which I really don't enjoy and actually stress me out a lot.
This one looks to have moved away from that a bit, so I may pick it up on Steam.