Mafia Round 1 - Tactical Appraisal | "Galaxy Go" - Page 2

Typhoid · 06-12-2009, 06:36 PM

!Vote Vampyr

Ric · 06-12-2009, 06:49 PM

Not so hasty there Qui Gon Jinn (Vampyr) if Chewbacca (Dylflon) truly is our seer then he must be protected for the Rebel cause. As such at this time I take your vote against him as a suspicious act.

*Locks Qui Gon(vampyr) in Cell next to Padme(Jeepnut)*

You can remain there until I resolve something.

Chewbacca (Dylflon), if truly you are Seer as you say you are, then as Seer you have the duty not only to investigate suspects but also to report the truth of those findings, anything other than reporting the truth of those findings would imo betray the laws of the mafia Star wars universe causing it to collapse in upon itself.

You may investigate once a night, that gives 2 investigations before sundays conclusion, I say you investigate yourself tonight and you have to tell us the truth because it is the law. That way any doubt is cleared up and we will know for sure if you lied. If you are as you say you are you should be afforded the protection you so desire. You are the only one to claim the title so far I suppose. But I trust no one. Perhaps the grand overseer (Bond) will tell us wether the results of the proposed investigation are true or false made up lies. If you report your investigation and say you are good then the grand overseer says you are lying then we will have the conformation we need. If he says you speak truth then we will know you truly are seer. Saturday night we investigate one of my current suspects should they not respond to questioning.

Darmani · 06-12-2009, 06:50 PM

Just reading through the posts it's hit me that voting in the first few rounds is going to be tricky business.
Also has any one seen my legs

Dylflon · 06-12-2009, 06:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ric

Not so hasty there Qui Gon Jinn (Vampyr) if Chewbacca (Dylflon) truly is our seer then he must be protected for the Rebel cause. As such at this time I take your vote against him as an act of evil.

*Locks Qui Gon(vampyr) in Cell next to Padme(Jeepnut)*

You can remain there until I resolve something.

Chewbacca (Dylflon), if truly you are Seer as you say you are, then as Seer you have the duty not only to investigate suspects but also to report the truth of those findings, anything other than reporting the truth of those findings would imo betray the laws of the mafia Star wars universe causing it to collapse in upon itself.

editing in progress message not finished do not reply to yet

Depends on what I find. I can't out good specials to the mafia. Also, outing normal good guys can be tricky too. The seer's usual protocol in these games is to build a secret network.

Dylflon · 06-12-2009, 07:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ric

You may invesyigate once a night, that gives 2 investigations before sundays conclusion, I say you investigate yourself tonight and you have to tell us the truth because it is the law. That way any doubt is cleared up and we will know for sure, if you are as you say you are you should be afforded the protection you so desire. Saturday night we investigate one of my current suspects should they not respond to questioning.

Two things wrong with that. I only can investigate once a round.

And seering myself makes absolutely no sense.

It wouldn't make any sense since I already know who I am, and since I can't copy and paste info from a PM, it proves nothing to anyone.

I know it's confusing because I think the rules say 'once per night' and that's actually how it's phrased in my role PM but that's going with the consideration that most rounds are only supposed to be one day long. The first round is usually longer to give everyone time to get on board.

Bond · 06-12-2009, 07:13 PM

Right, sorry. All special actions are once per round. This first round is especially long so everyone has time to read the rules, their role PMs, and post in this thread.

Remember, the narration (and the days within) are just fluff.

Ric · 06-12-2009, 07:18 PM

Quote me :

But I trust no one. Perhaps the grand overseer (Bond) will tell us wether the results of the proposed investigation are true or false made up lies. If you report your investigation and say you are good then the grand overseer says you are lying then we will have the conformation we need. If he says you speak truth then we will know you truly are seer.

Ok so I edited that post but that was while you were posting. What I am saying is, do we really just take your word that you are seer?

Oh only once per round, my mistake... hmm still...

EDIT: You cant QUOTE a pm. That does not mean you can not report upon the information contained within it. Otherwise I cant tell people that I am a Rebel (good) and I already have, several times.

Darmani · 06-12-2009, 07:23 PM

Just thinking about it now Dylflon
Why would you openly out yourself as the seer knowing full well the bad guys could kill you straight off.
I guess it's up to the gurdian to decide if he believes dylflon or not, because if he's telling the truth then he's prety much put himself in the crosshairs of the bad guys. And we're going to loose our seer very quickly.
But, the bad guys all know eachother, so for all we know this could be a trick by them to try and out the real seer.
I think you have put yourself in a very dangerous position Dylflon if you truely are the seer.

Swan · 06-12-2009, 07:25 PM

To carry on my Mafia tradition...

!Vote Vampyr

thatmariolover · 06-12-2009, 07:49 PM

So stoked. Always wanted to be Obi-Wan

Bond · 06-12-2009, 07:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ric

EDIT: You cant QUOTE a pm. That does not mean you can not report upon the information contained within it. Otherwise I cant tell people that I am a Rebel (good) and I already have, several times.

You can allege what your PM states in text (ie. whether you are good or bad, your special role), but you cannot screen cap the PM in this thread, any other thread, through private messages, or any other communication source.

BreakABone · 06-12-2009, 08:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dylflon

Alright, let's get this game going.

I have the unfortunate advantage of knowing a lot about Mafia games. This makes me the most likely target for the mafia to kill in the first night. This happened to Vampyr once - getting killed early for being crafty.

Now that would be fiiiiiiine and dandy except for the fact that I am the seer.

Now the predicament is that without a seer, the good side has a much lower chance of rooting out bad guys.

I know this is a huuuuuge leap of faith but I need the guardian to protect me this round, and allow me to do a bit of seering.

From there, I'll work on figuring out a way to build a network, but this is going to require a lot of trust which in this game is quite difficult. If the guardian could at the very least humour me for a few rounds, we might make some headway.

However, if you don't trust me, I'm definitely dead this round.

I need to get really lucky and seer a bad guy this round, because seering a regular good guy doesn't really help me prove anything.

Help me guardian; you're my only hope.

Sorry I had to.

Anyhow, that is a hell of a hail mary in the first round.
Was intrigued on how you would play the game being on the other side for once (as far as GT is concerned)

BlueFire · 06-12-2009, 08:21 PM

Argh.. Star Wars themed? The only movie I've seen is Episode III.

As always, whenever I start this game, I automatically become suspicious of BaB.. because it's him.

But I'll hold off for now.

thatmariolover · 06-12-2009, 08:37 PM

Haha, this is going to be so good.

Bond · 06-12-2009, 08:45 PM

It would be cool if everyone could change their avatar to their character like jeepnut and Teuthida have done.