Mafia Round 1 - Tactical Appraisal | "Galaxy Go"

[Ric]

Chewbacca if truly you are the seer then with all your previous experience you should know that outing yourself from the start seems like a very foolish idea. You make yourself the Imperial's prime target.

Originally Posted by Dylflon

The regular players know that mafia never put themselves in the spotlight early on.

You are contradicting yourself by your actions! You are apparently one of the guys with powers, why out yourself?

My vote remains the same, I do not trust you.

!Vote Dylflon-Chewbacca (Still)

[Bond]

Standings:

manasecret - 8
Dylflon - 3
Vampyr - 1
Combine - 1
Bube - 1


Make sure to get your vote, your two posts, and special power PMs in before the round ends tonight!

[BreakABone]

Just for the record Ric, if your vote isn't going to change, don't re-vote makes it confusing for the person trying to calculate the votes.

And just for the record since time has already gone... this is PM, right?

[Angrist]

Just getting my 2nd post in.

I read it all, and you really can't say much in round one.

In previous mafia games I've gone completely analytical, suspecting everyone and explaining why some are more suspicious than others.
But it rarely helped. Of my 5 accusations, only 2 were right.
And I don't have time for that anymore, since I'm pretty busy with my thesis.

So I'll just play it easy. I'm sticking with my manasecret vote, because he already said he probably wouldn't be able to play much.
I don't hear anyone whining about it though, so that could mean he's a good guy (bad guys would defend their team mate, right?).

[Bond]

Originally Posted by BreakABone

And just for the record since time has already gone... this is PM, right?

Yes, sorry.

[jeepnut]

The more I think about it, the more I am confused by Dylflon's move. True if you actually are the seer, this will hook you and the guardian up immediately. However, even if that does work, your handicapping the guardian by basically forcing him to guard you every round. Also, Dylflon can't possibly know anything yet, so I don't see what you gain by outing yourself this early.

I'm nervous about changing my vote this early in the game with no actions to base it on, but I also don't want to waste it on manasecret who from everything we can tell, is innocent. Oh well, what the hell. It's not going to change anything this round anyway.

!retract manasecret

!vote Dylflon

[Dylflon]

Originally Posted by Ric

Chewbacca if truly you are the seer then with all your previous experience you should know that outing yourself from the start seems like a very foolish idea. You make yourself the Imperial's prime target.



You are contradicting yourself by your actions! You are apparently one of the guys with powers, why out yourself?

My vote remains the same, I do not trust you.

!Vote Dylflon-Chewbacca (Still)

I feel like I'm trying to explain this to a brick wall. You really just don't understand what you're saying.

ONCE MORE: I OUTED MYSELF BECAUSE I'M THE MOST LIKELY TARGET TO BE KILLED ON THE FIRST DAY SINCE I HAVE THE MOST KNOWLEDGE ON HOW TO PLAY MAFIA GAMES.

It was a gambit I felt I had to take.


!vote Ric

[Dylflon]

Jeepnut:

In every mafia game I've run, the guardian usually just protects random people. I have only ever in three games of Mafia on this forum, seen a guardian successfully use his power twice.

Usually they're just crap shooting it. So giving the guardian a logical person to protect isn't handicapping them in any way.



I need to be able to live past the first round so I can start to form a network. I realistically am only going to survive a few rounds so I need to get stuff done fast.

I really can't see what I would accomplish if I was in the mafia and making a huge spectacle of myself. If I couldn't back up my claim in a few rounds I'd be dead.




Also, I'm in contact with someone claiming to be the vigilante. I'm seering them this round. If you guys humour me for one round, and that person is telling the truth, I'll be able to prove my identity by telling you who the vigilante is going to kill before the end of round tomorrow.

[Darmani]

Originally Posted by Dylflon

ONCE MORE: I OUTED MYSELF BECAUSE I'M THE MOST LIKELY TARGET TO BE KILLED ON THE FIRST DAY SINCE I HAVE THE MOST KNOWLEDGE ON HOW TO PLAY MAFIA GAMES.

In all honesty I don't think any one would of even thought of that, looking how the votes have swung and the posts, I don't think any one would have voted you out for being more expierienced.

I wont be changing my post because, I decided to go with my first instinct, which was to trust you. I believe you are the seer, but I still think you've made a foolish move outing yourself straight away, I do understand your reasoning for it, I just don't agree with it. I feel like you could of lasted one or two rounds at least before anyone started seeing your previous knowlege as a thret.

[Ric]

Originally Posted by Dylflon

I feel like I'm trying to explain this to a brick wall. You really just don't understand what you're saying.

ONCE MORE: I OUTED MYSELF BECAUSE I'M THE MOST LIKELY TARGET TO BE KILLED ON THE FIRST DAY SINCE I HAVE THE MOST KNOWLEDGE ON HOW TO PLAY MAFIA GAMES.

It was a gambit I felt I had to take.


!vote Ric

I understand perfectly what I am saying thankyou. I do not believe that you are the seer. I believe you are falsely seeking protection from the guardian.
I do not believe you would be prime target just because of your experience in previous games, and the thing I can not get my head round is that if you are the seer why in the hell did you out yourself, it is not logical.

Consider these possible scenarios -

*Possible Imperial Conversation 1*
'How do we out their seer?'
'Look...'

''over here''

'Blast the fool to smithereens'
*End*

*Possible Imperial Conversation 2*
'How do we out their seer?'
'We dupe them'
'What do you mean'
'I will say I am seer and see if anyone says' - 'no you are not I am'
'Then we will have our target... genius'
'Haa haaa haaaa (meniacal laughing)
*End*

I am watching you Chewbacca, intently.

But I am going to have to kill manasecret just for fun, he may as well be dead already
!retract Dylflon
!vote manasecret

EDIT: Sorry about this but I just have to go back on that. I simply do not believe you, I am going with my instinct, which tells me I smell a Sith.
!retract manasecret
!vote Dylflon

[Bube]

Originally Posted by Bond

It would be cool if everyone could change their avatar to their character like jeepnut and Teuthida have done.

NO!

Originally Posted by Nighthawk

ok I changed my mind...

!retract Angrist


!vote Bube

I have a feeling he's evil...

What the..?! How do feel that I'm evil?

Oh, and please consider this my 2 posts, I was too busy this weekend, and I don't feel like making 2 posts for spamming purposes.

And I must say, how can Dylflon be voted off by the evil ones? There are only 4 of them, they're never a majority. We just have to trust him. And if he isn't the seer, then the won't the real seer just find that out? Has this been discussed before, I haven't read every post in detail

!vote manasecret

[Typhoid]

(Just to make it easy)

The votes:



manasecret - 9
Dylflon - 3
Vampyr - 1
Combine - 1
Bube - 1
Ric - 1

[Typhoid]

Ric, if you change your votes as much as catholic girl changes her panties, don't edit your post after a vote update has been compiled, make a new post.


Updated (again) votes.


manasecret - 8
Dylflon - 4
Vampyr - 1
Combine - 1
Bube - 1
Ric - 1

[Combine 017]

Im going to have to
!vote Dylflon
on this one.

[Ric]

Originally Posted by Typhoid

Ric, if you change your votes as much as catholic girl changes her panties, don't edit your post after a vote update has been compiled, make a new post.

Ok but technically I did edit that post at the exact same time as you made yours so you cant really fault me on it. Next time I will just post a new one to save confusion though