The NFL thread 2004-2005

[Stonecutter]

Originally Posted by Perfect Stu

Also, question for Bond and Stoney:

How many games have you watched Manning play this year?

Vs NE
Vs GB
Vs Oak
Vs KC
Vs Min
Vs Chi
Vs Det

I watched at least half of all of those games except the KC game where I only got to see the last 5 minutes during some CBS Extended coverage.

Damn, Indy has been on a lot this year.

[Perfect Stu]

with the exception of NE, you saw him against cream puff defenses. Although shredding those apart, he was also amazing against teams like Jacksonville (twice) and Tennessee (when their defense was....alive?) who are potent defenses.

what makes you think Favre's the better QB?