Re: Artist Battle: Kyuzo vs. Vampyr (Art Submission)
Although anonymous, the judges were real people. With the exception of one, the other four judges are not active artists here on GT or elsewhere as far as I know. Even though they were randomly selected, I actually think having non-artists judging can be better. Because the judgments you receive from them are purely based on what they see. Unlike artists, who would also be to spot certain photoshop techniques, filters, effects, etc. By having people who can't spot that stuff, you get a more effective judgement because they're simply voting by what is plainly visible and the emotions that the picture evokes in them. Which is one of the fundementals of viewing art and creating it.
In my opinion, it's not important whether the judges are identified or not. Knowing their names won't change their true opinions. I actually believe that by keeping their identities a secret, you receive a more honest critique because no one has to worry about hurting feelings and ruining friendships.
Anyway, me and Vampyr are hard at work planning the future of Artists Battles here. It's likely that future battles will use polls to determine winners. That way, more people can vote and we won't having anyone questioning the truthfulness of the Royal Panel. And those who want to comment can post their opinions within the thread and those who want to remain anoymous won't have to post anything.
|
Threaded Mode
