MAFIA Scooby Doo Round 1

[BlueFire]

I think manasecret is lying. At least that's what I want to believe. What would he be gaining from revealing he is the enchanter? If he is a villager, he's just confusing us. If he's actually the enchanter, he's making the game easier for the villagers (assuming we think it's true).

I'm not changing my vote unless I'm convinced. I'd rather stick with my random vote..


EDIT: and now he posted before this.. hahah. Oh well. I'm sticking with my vote.

[ZebraRampage]

Originally Posted by takegiantsteps

I think manasecret is lying. At least that's what I want to believe. What would he be gaining from revealing he is the enchanter? If he is a villager, he's just confusing us. If he's actually the enchanter, he's making the game easier for the villagers (assuming we think it's true).

I'm not changing my vote unless I'm convinced. I'd rather stick with my random vote..


EDIT: and now he posted before this.. hahah. Oh well. I'm sticking with my vote.

I also think that he'd be making the game easier for the villagers if he's telling the truth because now we'll have 19 people to choose from instead of 20. I don't get why he'd be lying if he's a villager, because what would that do other than fuck with us if he doesn't really care about the game. I still think I have a good theory for SAVING a villager. If mana really is a villager, then he killed himself.

[manasecret]

Originally Posted by ZebraRampage

I also think that he'd be making the game easier for the villagers if he's telling the truth because now we'll have 19 people to choose from instead of 20.

Ok, that would be the case if I was mafia. Which would make no sense at all for me to do.

I don't get why he'd be lying if he's a villager, because what would that do other than fuck with us if he doesn't really care about the game. I still think I have a good theory for SAVING a villager. If mana really is a villager, then he killed himself.

That's where your theory is incorrect. I do care about the game, and I do care about making it fun. I'm lying as a villager because I figured everyone would know I was kidding because it would make no sense for me to do it as the enchanter.

I still have faith that everyone will realize that.