MAFIA Scooby Doo Round 1

[manasecret]

Originally Posted by BreakABone

Jinkies!

You have created quite the dynamic now haven't you.

If you are telling the truth, you are well protected and get to mess around with people's head, if you are lying, then why would you.

Must be the

[ZebraRampage]

Originally Posted by manasecret

You might as well not vote for me. I'm the Enchanter. I make love not war, and my love will never die.

Until all the others die. Then my love will die.

So where's Magus in all this? I saw him reading the thread, but no replies yet... hmmm, random accusation, ahoy hoy!

!retract Thespis

!vote Magus

All right, I have a theory on this.


Mana is either lying or he's telling the truth..obviously.


If he's telling the truth, then he is in enchanter, and there are three other mafia out there that we have to figure out first.

If he's lying, then he's either a villager just causing havoc, or he's just a regular mafia member. So, there is the chance that he could be in the mafia, which would make it worth it to vote for hiim.

If he really is the enchanter, and we vote for him, then at least we won't be voting off a village member. The mafia will kill off a villager, and the vigilante will probably kill a villager as well, so why would we want to risk killing a third villager when we could try to kill manasecret and find out if he's the enchanter or maybe just a regular mafia member?

I guess if he is the enchanter then it's a waste of a vote, but it could be worth it just to save more village members for the time being until we figure out more information.


What does everyone think of that theory?

[Bond]

I don't think enchanter is an actual role? It's normally just vigilante, seeker, and guardian.

[ZebraRampage]

Originally Posted by Bond

I don't think enchanter is an actual role? It's normally just vigilante, seeker, and guardian.

Originally Posted by Dylflon

Also, this game will see the introduction on The Enchanter which is the lead bad guy role. The Enchanter cannot be removed from the game until all other bad guy players are taken out. Once someone tries to remove The Enchanter from the game however, his identity will be revealed.

Look back to the first mafia thread.

[BreakABone]

Originally Posted by Bond

I don't think enchanter is an actual role? It's normally just vigilante, seeker, and guardian.

Sweet wasn't the only one who didn't read the rules thread.

Apparently the Enchanter is a new role for this game. The King Mafia as it were, in order for him to be eliminated, we must get rid of every other member of the Mafia.

With that said, I believe Zebra's theory to be sound so

!Retract Combine

!vote Manasecret

[Bond]

My bad, I should have read more closely.

Zebra's theory is interesting... I need to think about it more, though.

[magus113]

Originally Posted by ZebraRampage

All right, I have a theory on this.


Mana is either lying or he's telling the truth..obviously.


If he's telling the truth, then he is in enchanter, and there are three other mafia out there that we have to figure out first.

If he's lying, then he's either a villager just causing havoc, or he's just a regular mafia member. So, there is the chance that he could be in the mafia, which would make it worth it to vote for hiim.

If he really is the enchanter, and we vote for him, then at least we won't be voting off a village member. The mafia will kill off a villager, and the vigilante will probably kill a villager as well, so why would we want to risk killing a third villager when we could try to kill manasecret and find out if he's the enchanter or maybe just a regular mafia member?

I guess if he is the enchanter then it's a waste of a vote, but it could be worth it just to save more village members for the time being until we figure out more information.


What does everyone think of that theory?

I'm following you on this. I may have jumped on the random number train but I definitely don't think that should be any reason to start throwing votes out at me.

It's random, and in a sense it's fair considering we don't know anyone really.

I'm definitely gonna have to agree with the sense that we could be wasting a vote, but I think I can see this working out in the future IF manasecret is telling the truth.

So Teuthida you're safe on my end.

!retract Teuthida
!vote manasecret

[ZebraRampage]

Originally Posted by Bond

My bad, I should have read more closely.

Zebra's theory is interesting... I need to think about it more, though.

Well, we have nothing on BaB, and he could be good, and with my theory, we'll be saving a good guy, unless mana really is a good guy just fucking with everyone.

!retract Schadenfreude

!vote manasecret


It seems like you modified your post, Bond, because what I just wrote in my messages was in reference to you preferring to stick with BaB. It seems like you're contemplating that now.

[Xantar]

I'll jump on the bandwagon because I've actually held a six year old grudge against manasecret and I'm a penguin furry.

Whoops. TMI?

!retract jeepnut
!vote manasecret

[manasecret]

Haha helloooo guys, remember that the ones that speak the least, keeping a low profile are more often times the mafia. The mafia is laughing it up right now. I'm just having fun. Why would I come out and say I'm the enchanter?

And I actually made a mistake on magus. I thought he hadn't posted yet, but my memory goofed and it was that he hadn't been voted for yet.

And I don't want to catch any of the blame when you all kill me when I told you, loud and clear, the mafia are the ones keeping a low profile. I am not mafia.

[BlueFire]

I think manasecret is lying. At least that's what I want to believe. What would he be gaining from revealing he is the enchanter? If he is a villager, he's just confusing us. If he's actually the enchanter, he's making the game easier for the villagers (assuming we think it's true).

I'm not changing my vote unless I'm convinced. I'd rather stick with my random vote..


EDIT: and now he posted before this.. hahah. Oh well. I'm sticking with my vote.

[ZebraRampage]

Originally Posted by manasecret

I'm just having fun. Why would I come out and say I'm the enchanter?

Not our fault you've probably screwed yourself over.

[ZebraRampage]

Originally Posted by takegiantsteps

I think manasecret is lying. At least that's what I want to believe. What would he be gaining from revealing he is the enchanter? If he is a villager, he's just confusing us. If he's actually the enchanter, he's making the game easier for the villagers (assuming we think it's true).

I'm not changing my vote unless I'm convinced. I'd rather stick with my random vote..


EDIT: and now he posted before this.. hahah. Oh well. I'm sticking with my vote.

I also think that he'd be making the game easier for the villagers if he's telling the truth because now we'll have 19 people to choose from instead of 20. I don't get why he'd be lying if he's a villager, because what would that do other than fuck with us if he doesn't really care about the game. I still think I have a good theory for SAVING a villager. If mana really is a villager, then he killed himself.

[manasecret]

Originally Posted by ZebraRampage

Not our fault you've probably screwed yourself over.

See, this is what I don't want to get the blame for.

I could have just not stuck my head out and not had any fun.

Or I could have had some fun with the game. And that always gets the person blamed when they're voted for and turn out to be innocent.

Remember, you guys are voting for me. I'm not voting for me.

[ridkidjory]

so ill be out of town this weekend just a heads up and ill have no access to a computer. if it gets to round 2 while im gone please randomly vote for me